4203: 1 hand dmg in alb is too low needs 19% dmg increase

Reported by ★ Disrupter at Tue, 09 May 2017 19:04:51 UTC
gamemechanic bug


1h dmg is making less dmg then it should.
This is the formula for

100 % base dmg = EDPS * (your WS/target AF) * (1-absorb) * slow weap bonus * SPD * 2h weapon bonus

Knowing that is the 100% mark referred by the weapon specialization section. If you are completely unspecced, then the damage variance of your weapon will fall between 25-125% of this 100% mark. If you are fully specced (or overspecced), then the damage variance will be 100-150% of this mark

Taken from here http://talsyra.tripod.com/daocmechanics ... anics.html , PA in uthg and many other have been determined by the calculations from this web site because its very accurate and thrustworthy.

1h dmg my arms 1693 WS , thrust weap 3.4 spd, effective dps of weapon 15.4 vs a cleric 635 AF. 19% abs did number of hits and found Min dmg 89 shown 75(-14) and max dmg 129 shown 109(-20) thats from 100% to 144% dmg variation.

15.4 x (1693/635) x 0.73 x 1.042 x 3.4 = 106 dmg should be 100% which is min calculated by the ecuation with a max variation up to 159 dmg .

I found on uthg 89 dmg when it should be 106 dmg , showing that 1h dmg should be increased with 19% .

Reproduction Steps

1. make an arms and cleric lvl 50 templated equiped with same stats as i did

2.duel for testing purposes obtain min and max
3.compare min and max from Uthg with the min dmg and max dmg shown by the formula shown .

Intended Behavior

Check exactly what dmg is on uthg as i only got to a 100%-144% dmg variation on my test on uthg and increase min dmg to match the one from formula , adjust your melee dmg formula acordingly and also check dmg tables for Weapon skill to be shown properly and well calculated .


I have proof chatlogs from my uthg test 1h and the 1h dmg i calculated using the ecuation shown here from a thrustworthy web site http://talsyra.tripod.com/daocmechanics/base_damage_mechanics.html

1h uthg test pic showing Weap skil etc: http://i.imgur.com/kIqw372.jpg

What i got on uthg as min dmg is 19% lower then what the ecuation gave , its a big diference of dmg .


Issue was invalid:
3 players say this report is valid, 1 disagrees


Loading Comments...